Metrics to Tender External Audit as KPMG Steps Aside After Valuation Dispute

Metrics to Tender External Audit as KPMG Steps Aside After Valuation Dispute
Image: Maksym Kozlenko / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (cropped and colour overlay added)

Metrics Credit Partners’ ASX-listed trusts will put their external audit out to tender, with incumbent auditor KPMG not taking part, according to announcements by Metrics Master Income Trust (ASX: MXT) and Metrics Real Estate Multi-Strategy Fund (ASX: MRE) released on Monday.

The move follows a dispute between the manager and KPMG over valuations that in late September delayed the trusts’ audited accounts, triggered net asset write-downs and led to a freeze on redemptions from the unlisted wholesale funds behind the listed vehicles.

What was announced

The external audit will be tendered by the fund’s manager and responsible entity during the current financial year, according to the MXT announcement as summarised by TipRanks. The MRE announcement said KPMG “will not participate by mutual agreement” and will remain auditor until a change takes effect, subject to the consent of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), TipRanks reported.

The announcements did not name a timetable for appointing a new auditor.

Background: write-downs and frozen funds

Metrics, which manages about A$40 billion, according to Alternative Credit Investor, saw trading in its three listed trusts halted on 28 September. KPMG was unable to sign off the trusts’ financial reports by the 30 September deadline after reaching different conclusions on valuation inputs and probability weightings for certain unlisted commercial real estate equity investments, according to ASX filings cited by Alternative Credit Investor and Bushletter.

The resulting adjustments cut net tangible assets by 12.16 per cent at MRE, 10.08 per cent at Metrics Income Opportunities Trust (ASX: MOT) and 1.99 per cent at MXT. Applications and redemptions were suspended at the unlisted wholesale funds, which Bushletter reported as the MCP Wholesale Investments Trust, holding about A$6 billion, and the MCP Real Estate Debt Fund, holding about A$3.3 billion.

KPMG subsequently issued unqualified audit opinions on the trusts’ 2026 financial reports, lodged on 2 October, and MXT and MOT were reinstated to quotation on 5 October, according to Independent Investment Research (IIR). MXT’s audited net tangible assets were $1.9617 per unit at 30 June 2026.

IIR placed its ratings on MXT, MOT and the unlisted Metrics Direct Income Fund under review. In its most recent published update, dated 12 October, IIR said it had not seen an announcement that the suspension at the underlying wholesale funds had ended. “An unqualified audit opinion and reinstatement to quotation do not by themselves reaffirm a rating,” IIR said.

Valuations in the regulatory spotlight

The audit change comes as regulators sharpen their focus on how private credit assets are valued. Opening the ASIC Annual Forum in Sydney on Tuesday, ASIC Chair Sarah Court said private capital was playing a larger role, including through structures that draw in retail investors, and pointed to ASIC’s “scrutiny of valuations and disclosure in private markets”.

ASIC’s latest private credit review, published on 10 November, found many poor practices identified a year earlier persisted across the 24 funds examined, and the regulator has issued six interim stop orders since September.

Implications for investors

For investors in listed private credit trusts, the episode underlines that reported net asset values depend on valuation judgements that auditors may challenge, particularly for less liquid real estate and equity-like positions. A change of auditor does not itself alter any valuation, but the identity of the incoming firm and the outcome of the next audit cycle will be watched closely as a test of how the manager’s valuation approach holds up.

The status of the frozen wholesale funds, and whether and when redemptions resume, remains the key issue for unitholders.

Sources

Image: Maksym Kozlenko, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0; cropped and colour overlay added by FINA.